The presence of contract lecturers on the campuses may be a new phenomenon. But they have already become a subject of debate in academia.
Doubts are being aired on whether hiring temporary teachers to fill up vacancies would do the higher education sector any good at all.
The emergence of contract lecturers on our campuses began in the late 1990s as a fallout of the de-linking of pre-degree courses from the colleges. The Government had banned fresh appointments in order to absorb the excess hands rising from the move.
The freezing of appointments led to a shortfall in the number of teachers in different departments, especially with the introduction of various self-financing courses a few years ago.
While the universities turned to contract lecturers mainly to keep the academic schedules going, the colleges opted for them to support their new courses.
On contract
Today, there are hundreds of contract lecturers working in universities and colleges across the State. Kerala University has more than 40 contract lecturers in its different departments.
Calicut University is currently on a walk-in recruitment drive of contract teachers. Almost all departments have one or two teachers on contract.
There are hardly any self-financing institutions in the State, including university and college departments, without contract lecturers. There are some college departments where the guest faculty outnumber their permanent counterparts.
Contract lecturers are different from the guest faculty. The latter are generally experts in different fields and are used for inputs in the areas of their specialisation.
Academics and finance
Ask any university administrator about contract lecturers, and pat will come the reply: "They make a whole lot of economic sense." True, because contract lecturers are paid less than what the regular teachers get.
The University Grants Commission has fixed a consolidated monthly pay of Rs. 8,000 for a contract lecturer. This is equal to the initial basic pay of a regular teacher.
For the Government, this makes for good economics.
In colleges, the situation is different.
In colleges affiliated to Kerala University, contract lecturers who have passed the National Eligibility Test (NET) get Rs. 8,000 a month. Those without NET get Rs. 5,000. In some colleges, this amount was recently reduced to Rs. 2,000.
In colleges under Mahatma Gandhi University, there are dozens of contract teachers working for Rs. 100 an hour.
Even though there is a ceiling of Rs. 6,000 a month, they hardly get 60 hours a month to teach.
However, there are some who take home nearly Rs. 10,000 a month by teaching in two colleges.
The immediate outcome of the disparity in pay between contract and regular teachers has been a decline in the quality of teaching.
Quality of teaching
"The best of the unemployed teaching talent does not come to us because we do not pay as much as the private educational institutions. The people we get are those who are looking to get employed unmindful of the salary. This does not augur well for any institution of higher learning," says K. Sasikumar, Syndicate member of Kerala University.
He points out that even if there are capable hands among the contract lecturers, they can neither guide research scholars nor attend to examination-related work.
Another drawback of the contract system is that the lecturers are appointed for an academic year.
"All that contract lecturers can do is to take regular classes. They cannot plan for the years ahead and devote themselves to the department's research programmes," says Oommen V. Oommen, head of the Department of Zoology at Kerala University. He says he is against the system of teaching on contract.
Dr. Oommen agrees that there are good teachers among those on contract. "My point is, when you find good people among contract teachers, why not make them permanent? Then you get good teachers, who can also engage themselves in research work," he says.
V.S. Sasibhushanan Nair, head of the Department of Mass Communication at Calicut University, says contract faculty is in a way good. "It gives us an opportunity to see and evaluate a good performer. If a contract lecturer is found to be hard working and good, it naturally gives him a preference at the time of regular appointment," Prof. Nair says.
N. Omanakumari, head of the Department of Botany at Kerala University, is all praise for the teaching ability and commitment of the two contract lecturers at her department. "They are capable of guiding research scholars. But the rules do not favour them," she says.
Solutions
Any solution to this academic crisis? According to Daniel Kuzhithadathil, Principal of Mar Ivanios College, Thiruvananthapuram, appointment of permanent faculty is the only way out. His college has 21 lecturers on contract.
"Contract lecturers may leave when they get a better job, even if it is half-way into the academic year. The consequences are only too evident. Moreover, I have found that contract lecturers do not command as much respect from the students as the permanent faculty. So they have a problem in enforcing discipline. If things continue like this, our higher education system will collapse in a few years," he says. Contract lecturers are freelance teachers, says T.U. John, former principal of Maharaja's College, Kochi.
Mr. John says that the system of contract teaching is unjust. "The Government should stop it because it generates two types of teachers on the basis of payment.". Mr. John is, however, quick to add that contract lecturers will often perform better than the regular teachers. "They are up-to-date, hard working and sincere, because they have to prove themselves for a permanent job later," he says.
There are academicians who want the universities to let contract lecturers guide research scholars and take part in examination-related work. They find untenable the argument that the universities have little control over such teachers.
"Contract lecturers are the only ones whose classroom performance is assessed in any manner. For this reason, they put in their best before the students. If the university wants any control over such teachers in the matter of guiding research or for valuation work, it can add that clause in the contract," says a senior teacher at Kerala University.
Divided opinion
Contract lecturers too say permanent faculty would be better in the long run. According to Santhosh Thampy, who works on contract at the Institute of Management in Kerala, Thiruvananthapuram, contract lecturers cannot take on any project or consultancy work.
"No agency will fund a project headed by a lecturer whose term of employment is only 11 months," Mr. Thampy says.
The students too have a divided opinion on contract lecturers. Even while admitting that contract lecturers often become a problem, some of them say thattheir presence will improve the academic system.
Most students who took part in an academic discussion held recently in Kochi said contract lecturers generally lacked experience and, therefore, could not match their regular counterparts.
However, some of them preferred guest faculty to regular teaching staff on the ground that the former would be fresh and full of new ideas.
Lack of money is said to be the reason for the freezing of permanent appointments.
There are, however, those who say that it is not impossible to find a solution to this problem.
Call for interface
B. Ekbal, former Vice-Chancellor of Kerala University, argues that higher education can best be sustained only through an interface between universities, the Government and the industries.
He points out that new programmes in biotechnology, multimedia or say, opto-electronics cannot be sustained by a "floating population" of contract lecturers.
"At present there are no modalities, no checks and balances to allow private funds to flow into our institutions of higher learning. It is my experience that there are a lot of organisations which are willing to fund programmes of higher learning. Once a synergy is achieved between these institutions and our universities, the problem of lack of money for higher education can almost fully be solved," he says. "Unfortunately, we are yet to take meaningful initiatives on these lines."
The situation, today, is that our academic institutions are neither willing to allow contract faculty the academic freedom necessary for the optimum utilisation of their skills, nor are they in a position to force the Government to allow appointment of permanent staff in necessary numbers in the teaching departments and the affiliated colleges.
No comments:
Post a Comment